What are your favourite music releases of this year? Do you like the direction pop music is going?
R—Yes. Both Caleb and me completely agree on that. I think music has progressively gotten better because it’s competing with underground artists, in a sense, because underground artists can now grab just as much attention as a pop artist with good releases. Anybody that records technically competes, if we’re looking at this though the lens of seeing, if we’re looking at music as this capitalistic thing, you’re competing. Hip hop is so creative right now because of underground hip hop on Soundcloud. You can chart on Billboard now with just a Soundcloud link, whereas before you had to go through these pre-historic channels. But, I guess as far as new music goes, right now that new Katy Perry is what I’m listening to. Also, the new Phoenix album actually has all these references to 70’s Italian disco and is by far the best songs they’ve ever written, and the production is right down our alley. I really hope it does well.
If it was possible to make a budgeted underground movie that could stand up quality-wise to films that you could go to the theatre and see, would the newest movies progressively get better? That’s the reason I think music has gotten progressively better. You walk into any indie store right now and Mac Demarco’s new record is playing and the Porches record from last year is sitting right next to the major pop releases, and both of those records are home recorded. There’s no equivalent of that in almost any other form of art right now.
I like that you guys aren’t afraid to appreciate pop music like the new Katy Perry record. I think this openness is encapsulated by the title of your record, Youth Music. That’s so vague nowadays, because what is “youth music”? It could be anything.
R—Exactly, a big part of [choosing] that [title] was that it feels huge, and the topic of the record was huge. I have slowly lost a lot of the "wonder" when it comes to new music. Even though I’m still so obsessed with it, I feel like four or five years ago when I was in school, following bands and music culture would completely absorb my life. I just wanted to make a record with Caleb that had enough culture around it so that people could feel the obsession that both of us felt when we were young.
C—For me, a part of appreciating modern pop music is the fact that, by its own nature, a lot of indie music has this goal of trying to win you over with authenticity. By its own nature, it’s inauthentic.
R—You’re marketing your authenticity.
C—If you’re trying to market authenticity, it’s inauthentic in the first place. At least on face value with pop music, you understand what you’re going to get. I like that, I don’t like the fake message of authenticity, and authenticity is boring. When you can do whatever you want and it’s boundless with technology and your mind, why would you choose to make something “authentic”, when we already have to deal with real life enough?
I just kind of get sick of that entire, “Oh, I’m going to dismiss anything popular because it’s inauthentic.” There’s this whole argument about ghostwriters right now, and I just think you should completely accept collaboration in music as long as it produces a better product in the end. People think it’s inauthentic if there’s 10 people sitting in the room writing the song, but that group is coming up with better songs. They are there for a job, and that job is to make good content.
Have you guys heard the new Selena Gomez song, “Bad Liar”? It samples Talking Heads, which is interesting when talking about authenticity, because in 2017 she can do that. She can sample Talking Heads and still be pure pop.
C—That song was blowing my mind. I know her last single was minimal, but the direction of that sample and the way the melodies worked, and the Petra Collins-directed video… All of these artists are dipping into “indie” for cred, but it’s still hugely pop. A lot of what Carly Rae did a couple years ago where she included Dev Hynes, parading them around on Saturday Night Live for indie cred—yet it’s still the hugest pop shit in the world. It’s incredible to me.
It goes back to the conversation we were having, where Carly Rae is almost having to compete with Dev Hynes. It’s like The Weeknd sampling “Pale Shelter” by Tears for Fear. You can just build a song by appropriating from another artist. I don’t know if it’s the producer of The Weeknd track showcasing their own music taste into the track, which I think is bizarre to be able to show and influence like that, or if it’s an appeal to a demographic. But it doesn’t matter in the long run, because either way people are going to listen to that song because it’s awesome, you know?